20 Best Bake Sale Ideas to Make Money and Why Each Rocks

If you’re a parent unsure of what to bring to the next bake sale, guess what?

You’re not alone.

You may wonder what people want.

Chocolate chip cookies are great, but what if you want to do something different?

Here, you’ll learn what the 20 best bake sale ideas are, and of course, why each rock! Put a new spin on the chocolate cookies with something fun.

 

What Makes a Good Bake Sale Idea?

A good bake sale idea involves you really being creative and trying something new.

Remember, this is fundraising, so being a little more adventurous and creative isn’t a bad idea.

A good bake sale item involves:

• It tastes good—obviously!
• It is a little bit creative
• It is packaged nice—people pass over crumpled cookies and crumbs

With that in mind, let’s look at the 20 best bake sale ideas to try for your next fundraiser.

 

20 Best Bake Sale Ideas to Try

Here are some different bake sale ideas, and below them, we’ll go over what they are and exactly why they’re the perfect addition for your next bake sale!

 

1. Trix Treats

Trix treats may seem strange, but they are a great way to use that sugary Trix you don’t want to have all the time.

They also work great for birthday parties.

Think of them as bars, but with a marshmallow filling between them and a few other ingredients.

Why this Rocks

It’s Trix.

It’s sweet.

It’s treats.

This is definitely unique and a good way to really make a splash if you’ve ever wanted to try some fun bake sale items.

You can check out this recipe from What mommy does to make it!

 

2. Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies

This is a great way to put a spin on peanut butter cookies.

They’re also incredibly simple to make too, and it combines peanut butter and chocolate into a totally amazing treat.

Why this Rocks

They’re very easy to make, and they also are pretty cute too.

Plus, both adults and kids love them.

You can get the recipe from Taste of Home to try it.

 

3. Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar

This is one that is made with chocolate but is like a bar.

However, think of it as a cookie, but in bar form.

Why this Rocks

Chocolate chip cookies but in bars? It’s so simple why people like it.

They are also easy to make, and you can actually cut them into bars easily.

Plus, you can drizzle sprinkles and chocolate on them for even more creative fun.

You can get the recipe from Today’s Parent.

 

4. Unicorn Bark

This looks like something instagrammable, but take the bark that people like and make it pretty.

That’s unicorn bark.

They can be a fun color, and they’re presented so well that people will flock to them.

Why this Rocks

It’s colorful, has sprinkles, and it tastes great! It definitely will shine the next bake sale.

Get the recipe here.

 

5. Mouth-watering Brownies

Brownies are always a good treat, and while they’re a classic recipe, they do make the biggest money.

Why this Rocks

For those who don’t want to make Instagram-level bark, this is simple, and you can make these with a deep chocolate flavor and some fudge.

Plus, if you want to make these really nice, you just use quality chocolate to offer the best option for people to buy.

 

6. Chiffon Cake

Chiffon cake is a coconut cake, so while it may not be what most people think of when they assume bake sales, if you’re selling to adults or an older audience, this tropical-flavored cake is different ad interesting.

Why this Rocks

It’s sweet, it tastes great, and it has some wonderful chocolate flavors and a great texture to it.

To learn to make it, check out this recipe.

 

7. Muesli Coffee Cake

Another interesting cake, this one is a coffee cake, so it may not be ideal for the kids, but it’s a wonderful cake.

It is pretty interesting in terms of taste, but it also is unique and fun.

Why this Rocks

Coffee cake has a great sweet taste, and people love cake.

It is a great way to bring something unique to the bake sale.

Try this recipe from Martha Stewart.

 

8. Chocolate Whoopie Pies

This is a great and sweet treat that is also a little bit tangy too.

Whoopie pies are two cake pieces together with a cream frosting in the middle.

Why this Rocks

It’s a sweet little sandwich treat, and it’s a great one that offers a rich taste that’s subtle too.

This recipe can be found here to try out.

Also See: Best Food Ideas to Sell to Make Money.

 

9. Smores Brownies

Mmm s’mores.

A classic treat made in s’mores form.

This is a sweet treat that’s unique and perfect for your next bake sale.

Why this Rocks

It harnesses the shape of a brownie but also incorporates the sweet taste of s’mores, so it certainly is something that you will enjoy.

You can get this recipe by checking it out on Delish.

 

10. Chocolate Covered Cake Balls

You can also do this with vanilla, but they’re literally balls with a covering of vanilla or chocolate over this.

They’re sweet, small, and simple, and you can bake these in your average pan.

Why this Rocks

It’s a very simple recipe to make and offers something different.

Plus, they’re the perfect sweet treat to try out.

You can get the recipe from here.

 

11. Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter and Pretzel Cookies

Sure, chocolate chip cookies are wonderful, but what if you did something different.

What if you had them with chocolate chips, pretzels, and peanut butter? Well, you can do that with this.

You can get the recipe from the Real housewife of Fredrick  County.

Why this Rocks

With the perfect taste of salty and sweet, this is wonderful and a great option if you want something good.

 

 

12. Kentucky Derby Bars

This is one for those nut lovers out there, but it’s a simple, popular take on the derby pie, but in the form of little bars.

Why this Rocks

It is decadent, but also good for you.

Don’t tell the kids that it’s healthy, with all the nuts and other ingredients.

Instead of making a derby pie, you just make bars, and that’s simple but effective.

You can get the recipe from Two Healthy Kitchens.

 

13. Minty Brownies

Mmm mint.

You can now get it in the form of brownies.

If you’re tired of always bringing the same old brownies, try this.

They’re a mint chocolate taste, and they use white chocolate with a chocolate ganache.

Why this Rocks

If you’re running a St. Patrick’s Day bake sale, this is amazing, but also, they’re an interesting and unique bake sale item.

It will definitely stand out from the brownies and other items!

You can get the recipe from Awesome on 20!

 

14. Cookie Bars

Want to make something different than a normal cookie? Why not do it in the shape of a bar.

These salty and sweet bars are peanut butter and chocolate flavor, and they include a pretzel filling.

Why this Rocks

This is convenient because it’s a bar, and many people also enjoy that it tastes good and sweet too.

You can get the recipe from Taste of Home.

 

15. Butterfinger Bites

These are similar to the candy but in a small bite shape with chocolate on top.

Simple and elegant, people can get a small baggie of these to go, and they’re great for selling at bake sales.

Why this Rocks

This one is less about the contents and more about the packaging since you can put this in containers that really make it shine.

And not just that, they taste really good too and are a wonderful addition.

You can try these Butterfinger Bites here.

 

16. Blueberry Ginger Muffins

While not everyone likes muffins, for health-conscious audiences, these might be a better sweet treat.

Plus, they’re great breakfast items and simple to make.

Why this Rocks

This is one of the “healthier” items on our list, but they are cute, and not everyone brings muffins, so they’ll probably get bought at the bake sale.

You can learn to make these here.

 

17. Ice Cream Cone Cupcakes

Ice cream at a bake sale?

More likely than you think!

You can take cupcakes and put a spin on them by putting them in ice cream cones, then dripping a topping over them.

Why this Rocks

It’s simple.

It’s ice cream and a cupcake.

It is a fun treat and a spin on, well, cupcakes which are always good.

You can get the recipe from here.

 

18.  Rice Krispy Treats

Rice Krispy treats may seem generic, but they’re always a hit at bake sales.

They also are very simple to make and are basically just sweet rice squares.

They also take about 10 minutes to fully make.

Why this Rocks

It’s simple, it’s sweet, and people love to buy these.

You can even make them unique, like these salted rice treats here.

 

19. Candy Cane Fudge

For those Christmas parties, try this one!

Candy cane fudge is a simple sweet treat to make.

It also has the minty taste of candy cane here.

Why this Rocks

Fudge is like brownies but offers just a chocolate brick without the crumbliness of brownies.

It also has the sweet taste of candy cane on top.

These are perfect for Christmas, and you can make them from the recipe from Mama Likes to Cook.

 

20. Marshmallow Cookies!

These are a wonderful, sweet treat for the colder months.

Got some hot chocolate and marshmallows lying around?

You can make cookies with this, and they are unique and fun and a good alternative for those who don’t want the pumpkin spice.

Why this Rocks

They’re simple, sweet, and you definitely can capture the satisfaction of drinking hot chocolate by eating these wonderful cookies.

You can get the Recipe from here.

 

Bake Sale Ideas to Make Money FAQs

 

What Makes a Good Bake Sale Item?

A good bake sale item has to be unique and creative but also tastes good too.

Presentation is a big part of this, and you can present a nice little sweet treat that also tastes amazing too.

In general, you want to make sure that you don’t bring the same item as someone else, and that’s what matters the most at the end of the day.

 

What Are the Most Popular Items for Bake Sales?

The most popular items for bake sales include brownies, cookies, and cupcakes.

While bars and small pastries normally aren’t seen at bake sales since they take a while to make, there are now more people making other sweet treats that are unique.

There are now cupcake variants that give the normal bake sale item treat a unique spin, especially if everyone else is bringing cupcakes.

 

Can You Make Lots of Money Selling Cookies?

You sure can!

But of course, not everyone wants to buy the same chocolate chip cookie five times.

If you can bake cookies but give them variants, this is a great way to make some serious cash.

You also can make different kinds of cookies.

Chocolate chip ones aren’t the only cookies to make.

There are tons of variation, so don’t be afraid to explore it.

You can make some good money at bake sales as long as you have ample qualities of items that look good.

 

Conclusion

Bake sales are a fun, fast way to raise money for different causes.

Whether it’s girl scouts, or just for a school, or maybe for a charity or your own nonprofit, bake sales are one of the best ways to make some money.

These are some of the hottest bake sale items to choose from, and you can make these easily, and from there really give them a nice spin to it, and one that will definitely raise funds.

Go have fun making these since most of these have the recipes here, and you’ll be able to start making them right away!